google-site-verification: google4283fb30fde0af74.html
top of page


Edwin Friedman

A Failure of Nerve

A Failure of Nerve

Part I:  Description

A Failure of Nerve: Redefining Leadership in Our Anxious Age

In "A Failure of Nerve," Edwin H. Friedman challenges traditional views of leadership, arguing that the most effective leaders are NOT charismatic heroes, but those who can manage their own anxiety and foster a sense of calm, differentiated presence within themselves and the systems they lead.

Key Concepts of a Failure of Nerve

  • Emotional Reactivity vs. Self-Differentiation: When feeling pressured, it's easy to revert to fight-or-flight, either aggressively pushing one's agenda or becoming paralyzed. Differentiated leaders resist this urge, staying grounded enough to make strategic choices.

  • Systems Thinking: Leaders don't exist in a vacuum. Friedman draws on family systems theory, showing how anxiety reverberates through organizations, schools, communities, etc.

  • The Illusion of "Quick Fixes: Seeking easy solutions is a natural response to anxiety, but it usually backfires. True leadership involves tolerating discomfort in service of long-term goals.

  • Taking Responsibility, Not Blame: Differentiated leaders focus on what they can influence, accepting there are forces outside their control. They avoid scapegoating and empower those around them.

Why "A Failure of Nerve" Resonates

  • Timeless Insights: Even though written decades ago, it speaks to our current era of rapid change, divisiveness, and the lure of demagogues.

  • Leadership Beyond Business: Though Friedman draws examples from business, his ideas are applicable to anyone leading teams, families, or navigating social change.

  • Challenging to Implement: The concepts are deceptively simple. True self-differentiation takes consistent, non-glamorous inner work.

Disclosure: The Nexus Initiative LLC participates in the Amazon Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program that earns us referral fees by advertising and linking to without any extra cost to you. By purchasing through us, you help us to able to continue to offer complimentary, highly curated content such as this listing. We thank you for your support.

Part II:  Common Questions

This book seems aimed at CEOs or politicians. Is it relevant for me?

  • Answer: Absolutely! Friedman defines leadership broadly:

    • Anyone Influencing Others: Whether you manage a team, parent a child, or advocate for social change, how you handle your OWN reactivity impacts those around you.

    • The Ripple Effect: A calmer parent raises more emotionally regulated kids, a less anxious teacher creates a better classroom climate, etc. Differentiation has far-reaching benefits.

Isn't it a leader's job to BE decisive? This book makes self-differentiation sound like waffling.

  • Answer: There's a crucial distinction between:

    • Reactive Decisiveness: Jumping to action under pressure, often based on fear or pleasing others. This might SEEM strong, but can backfire long-term.

    • Grounded Choice: A differentiated leader gathers data, tolerates the discomfort of uncertainty long enough to assess the situation thoughtfully, then acts strategically.

The book emphasizes the leader's own emotional state. But shouldn't the focus be on the external challenges?

  • Answer: Friedman's core argument is they're interconnected:

    • Anxious Leaders = Anxious Systems: If the leader panics, it spreads. If they're the calmest person in the room, it helps everyone else think more clearly.

    • External Problems are Amplified: Mismanaged internal anxiety leads to poor decisions, infighting, etc., worsening the initial issue.

    • It's a Starting Point: Leaders can't fix everything, but their level of differentiation has a big impact on the system's overall capacity to function under stress.

Isn't 'not taking things personally' just teaching people to be doormats?

  • Answer: It's about finding the balance between:

    • Over-Reactivity: Getting hooked into every conflict prevents strategic action.

    • Apathy: A differentiated leader still has values and takes a stand. But they do so from a place of inner strength, not knee-jerk defensiveness.

How do I actually BECOME more self-differentiated? The book offers the theory, but not many tools.

  • Answer: You're right, it's conceptually focused. Here's where to start:

    • Awareness is Step One: Notice when you feel emotionally hijacked. Just label it ("There's the panic, trying to take over").

    • Tiny Pauses: Before reacting, buy yourself even a few seconds to breathe and check your gut impulse.

    • Seek Support: Therapists familiar with systems thinking can help. Even discussing these ideas with trusted colleagues can help you spot your less differentiated moments.

Part III:  Additional Books Of Interest

The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People by Stephen R. Covey: 

  • Covey's classic work emphasizes taking responsibility for our choices and focusing on proactive problem-solving, aligning with Friedman's call for self-differentiated leadership.

Leadership and Self-Deception: Getting Out of the Box by The Arbinger Institute:  

  • This book explores how self-awareness is critical for leaders to overcome self-sabotaging mindsets and make clear decisions that serve the greater good.

Thinking, Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman:  

  • Kahneman's exploration of two systems of thinking (fast, intuitive thinking versus slower, more rational thought) can help leaders understand the sources of bias and reactive decision-making.

Dare to Lead by Brené Brown:  

  • Brown emphasizes leading with courage and vulnerability, compassionately connecting with others while tackling difficult issues directly – concepts Friedman advocates for.

Immunity to Change: How to Overcome It and Unlock the Potential in Yourself and Your Organization by Robert Kegan and Lisa Laskow Lahey:  

  • This work focuses on identifying the internal "mental models" that hold us back and developing strategies to shift limiting beliefs and behaviors.

Part IV:  Disclaimer

These results were largely generated by Google Gemini and updated with additional content by us on a case-by-case basis. To make this amount of complimentary content available at a cost-effective level for our site visitors and clients, we have to rely on, and use, resources like Google Gemini and other similar services.

bottom of page