google-site-verification: google4283fb30fde0af74.html
top of page

Secondary Gain

Part I:  Description

What is Secondary Gain?

  • Definition: Secondary gain refers to the benefits someone might unconsciously or consciously receive from an illness, injury, or psychological condition. These benefits are separate from the primary symptoms and can perpetuate or worsen the condition itself.

Types of Secondary Gain:

  • Tangible Gains: Financial compensation, time off from work/school, avoiding unpleasant tasks.

  • Intangible Gains: Increased attention, sympathy, avoiding difficult situations or responsibilities.

Importance of Understanding Secondary Gain: 

Recognizing secondary gains is crucial in several fields:

  • Medicine: Can aid in identifying why some patients don't improve despite treatment.

  • Psychology: Helps therapists understand motivational factors impacting behavior.

  • Legal: Used in insurance claims or disability benefits cases.

How Does Secondary Gain Differ from Malingering?

  • Key Difference: Malingering involves faking or exaggerating symptoms for a specific, conscious gain. Secondary gain can be less deliberate or even unconscious.

Part II:  Common Questions

1. What is an example of secondary gain?

Answer: A common example is a person with chronic back pain who receives extra attention and care from their family. This increased attention, while well-intentioned, might inadvertently reinforce the pain behaviors and hinder recovery.

2. Is secondary gain always intentional?

Answer: No, secondary gain can often be unconscious. The individual may not be consciously seeking the benefits, but their behavior might be subtly influenced by the advantages they experience.

3. How can secondary gain impact treatment?

Answer: If secondary gains are significant, they can create an obstacle to treatment success. A person might unconsciously resist recovery if it means losing the benefits they've gained from their condition.

4. Does secondary gain mean someone is faking an illness?

Answer: Not necessarily. While malingering involves intentionally faking symptoms for a specific gain, secondary gain can involve genuine symptoms. The focus is on the additional advantages that may be unconsciously influencing the condition's persistence.

5. How is secondary gain addressed in therapy or treatment?

Answer:  Addressing secondary gain often involves:

  • Increasing awareness: Helping the individual recognize the benefits they might be getting.

  • Shifting focus: Working to create positive reinforcement for healthy behaviors and progress.

  • Problem-solving: Developing strategies to address the underlying needs being met by the secondary gain in healthier ways.

Part III:  Additional Resources

Books about Secondary Gain

"Neurology and Clinical Neuroscience" (Mosby):

  1. Offers a comprehensive medical perspective on secondary gain, including its role in diagnosis and treatment.

"Approach to Internal Medicine: A Resource Book for Clinical Practice" (Springer):

  1. Examines secondary gain within the broader context of medical assessment and decision-making.

"Coaching With NLP For Dummies" (John Wiley & Sons):

  1. Explores secondary gain from a coaching perspective, helping practitioners identify and address it in clients.

Online Articles and Websites about Secondary Gain

  1. Verywell Mind: "What Is Secondary Gain?": Provides a concise definition and examples of secondary gain in various situations.

  2. Psychology Today: Search for "Secondary Gain" ( Features various blog posts and articles written by therapists offering insights into secondary gain in mental health.

  3. Cleveland Clinic: "Functional Disorders": While not solely dedicated to secondary gain, this resource explains how it can be a factor in functional disorders.

  4. The National Institutes of Health (NIH) / Medline Plus ( Search for "secondary gain" to access reliable medical information.

Other Resources about Secondary Gain

  1. Professional training workshops: Consider workshops on disability assessment, pain management, or psychotherapy, which often address secondary gain.

  2. Scholarly journals: Search for articles on secondary gain in psychology, medical, or legal journals.

  3. Reputable therapy directories: Find therapists who specialize in areas where secondary gain is relevant (chronic pain, trauma, etc.) – their insights can be valuable.

Part IV:  Disclaimer

These results were highly selected, curated, and edited by The Nexus Inititiative. To make this amount of complimentary content available at a cost-effective level for our site visitors and clients, we have to rely on, and use, resources like Google Gemini and other similar services.

bottom of page